Cowslip or Oxlip?

Cowslips are a common sight in April and May – brightening up grasslands and motorway verges with their swathes of nodding yellow flower heads. When I first started out in botany, I spent a good while convincing myself that the cowslips were indeed cowslips and not oxlips – Rose’s wildflower key tells you that cowslip is like oxlip but the ‘leaves are more wrinkled and the stem is more gradually tapered to the base’ which requires a certain amount of experience to compare! Luckily the sniff test (cowslip flowers smell like apricots) saw me right!

One simple rule of thumb is location  – true oxlips are a rare ancient woodland species restricted to the part of the country where the counties of Cambridgeshire, Suffolk and Essex meet. Unless you are in a location like this, you are unlikely to be encountering oxlip. But to be on the safe side, here’s a few more pointers!

Cowslip – Primula veris

IMG_9700
Cowslip flowers at Cribbs Meadow – the bright yellow bell-shaped flowers at the top of the stems all nod in a single direction

The flowers of cowslip, like those of oxlip, form a nodding head facing in a single direction. They can be long-stemmed – up to 25cm tall, but are often shorter where the nutrient levels are lower. The flowers are deep yellow with orange flecks in the centre.

IMG_8342.JPG
Cowslip flower at Muston Meadow showing the orange flecks within the flowers – these smell of apricot if you get in close!

You can find up to 30 flowers in a flower head, or sometimes just a few. Remember to take a sniff – the apricot aroma is quite distinctive in a fresh flower!

Oxlip – Primula elatior

IMG_2917.jpg
Oxlip flowering at Hayley Wood – the flowers nod in a single direction and there can be 10-30 in an umbel

Oxlip, as mentioned above, is a rare native found in ancient woodland in a restricted area of the country. If you are encountering the species on a roadside verge or in a meadow in Nottinghamshire, it’s probably not an oxlip. However the species can be bought as a plant, or grown from seed, so it is quite possible it can spring up in unexpected places if it escaped the confines of its sowing!

The oxlip is similar in structure and stature to the cowslip, in growing to ~25cm high and having 10-30 flowers on a head. As with the cowslip, all of the flowers will be nodding on the same side of the stem.

IMG_2865
The oxlip flowers are more open and spreading, lacking the bell-shape of the cowslip. They are generally a paler yellow, and lack the orange flecks inside.

The oxlip flower is less bell-shaped than the cowslip, with more open spreading petals and a lighter, paler yellow. The centres of the flowers lack the orange spots usually found with cowslip.

False oxlip – Primula vulgaris x veris 

IMG_8353
False oxlip along the Grantham Canal – the flowers have the orange flecks of the cowslip but spread wider, reflecting the primrose part-parantage of this hybrid. The flowers face in all directions, rather than nodding in a single aspect.

Just to add to the confusion, there is another species which can be confused with both cowslip and oxlip and this is the false oxlip. The latin name is Primula vulgaris x veris reflecting the fact that a false oxlip is in fact a cross between a primrose and a cowslip, occuring where these two species are found in close proximity. If you find something which you suspect to be an oxlip outside of the correct habitat and geographical area, a false oxlip is your most likely suspect!

The flowers are more open and spreading, a little like an oxlip, but you can see the telltale orange flecks which indicate the cowslip parantage. Rather than nodding in a single direction, as a pure oxlip or cowslip would do, these flowers face in all directions. There is significant variability in the character or these hybrids, with some being closer to the primrose parent and some more strongly representing cowslip.

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Cowslip or Oxlip?

  1. Malcolm July 24, 2012 / 7:06 pm

    By accident I have arrived at your blog. Upon looking through the pages my attention was drawn to the picture of what you call Oxlip. Are you sure it is Oxlip? Your excellent photo convinces me that the plant is a Cowslip. These are the characters that I have used to identify the plant.

    [1] The flower in your picture is more bell shaped than I would expect for an Oxlip. The Oxlip flower is much more open, [more like that of a Primrose].

    [2] The Cowslip flower is a much deeper, brighter yellow than the Oxlip which is usually a pale yellow.

    [3] The calyx of the Cowslip is uniformly pale green but that of the Oxlip has darker, green midribs.

    If the hairs on the plant in your photograph were clearly visible that would also help determine the species. The hairs of the Cowslip are short and straight while those of the Oxlip are short and crisped.

    [Reference: ‘New Flora of the British Isles’ by Clive Stace]

    From a member of the BSBI.

    • Grantham Ecology July 24, 2012 / 7:30 pm

      You’re entirely right; how embarrassing to have mixed it up in the photo for an ID post, sloppy captioning! Thanks for your additional ID comments too – although I was concentrating on that one characteristic, the others from Stace make for a much more robust guide to differentiating. I’ll try to add an oxlip photo next spring for comparison.

      Thanks again for taking the time to correct my mix-up!

  2. Nerissa's Life August 6, 2014 / 5:57 pm

    Does the Oxlip have no scent at all or just not that of apricots?

  3. Patricia April 12, 2015 / 5:07 pm

    I thought an easy way to tell them apart is that the flowers of cowslips hang down (like udders!) but oxslips are more horizontal

  4. Helen April 11, 2016 / 8:18 am

    This year, what seemed to be primroses have mad in my garden. I still don’t know without doing the sniff test whether they are cowslip or oxslip but at least I now have a better idea of what is going on!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s